You must be logged in to post Login

Search Forums:


 






Two week Breaks

UserPost

5:52 am
February 8, 2010


Bounty

CA

Deep One

posts 244

First, let me freely acknowledge that I am one of the biggest whiners among the true believers when it comes to the prior Hobbyist tendencies of the Property. Just tonight in fact I made a passive-aggressive comment on the Mythmakers situation.


That said though, I've rarely had a problem with the quality, or appropriateness of side treks, just their bloody frequency.


Also, while the reigning d**k of never-misses-a-day web comics over at LICD hasn't ran a single guest comic EVER, every other professional or semi-professional comic I read does run them. Now I can't say I read them all, or even all the professional ones, (Penny Arcade being one I don't, and that may apply) but that seems to be a pretty solid rule.


We all know WHY you need the breaks, and you'll never hear anyone who isn't trolling say that they'd give up some of the amazing quality on the books for a shorter down period. Still, if you want to take the 2 week down time to run a Starkweather preview of 5 pages, an Angels/SG cross-over strip a bunch of Sporkbot and Master-Futon's better pieces, or even just the rest of that Mysthmakers story, all of that is fine. Piro does it, and he's published with DC now. Scott Sava does it, and he's at 1022 with only a single unplanned down time, and he's selling his comic for movies.

The professionals do it. They just make sure that it's 6 strips max in between 32-90 solid posts of on-time awesome sauce. That's all I ask ;)

It's time for another good idea, bad idea:
Good Idea – Getting your Insider character into the comic
Bad Idea – Joining the EOD to do so.

Gratz to Jacobus for the New Avatar!

11:05 am
February 8, 2010


Kaden

Ohio

Fish Monster

posts 9

I can understand separating the content generated by other people into a different section as a method of showing focus on the main story line.  Both side stories and fan work have their place, and excluding it from the main site shouldn't be a problem as long as it is not to hard to find from the main site.  With a realistic plan for the schedule of updates you should be able to use filler as extra content instead of an excuse.  Whatever schedule you can consistently meet is fine for the main comic.  While I'd like more frequent comics, as I'm sure others do, reliable quality updates are just as important.

2:49 pm
February 8, 2010


Dave Reynolds

North… Just north.

Elder God

posts 310

I just wanna clarify something here. When we said no fill-in artists, we didn't say anything about guest creators. There is a difference between the two. For example, Egg Embry and James Suhr doing a short story is guest deal. So would be Alan Evans' Shadow/Angels crossover. Those are self contained stories that fell into the appropriate place and didn't disrupt the flow of the ongoing story. We don't have a problem with those and in fact, I find them awesome. (I love seeing other people have takes on our characters.)

What we're talking about is those times where a page is running late (which is something that we endeavored to prevent from happening again) and to "fill in" the update, we'd post art a fan or friend drew, or a Shadowbabies strip or something like that. That's what we're talking about. We have an art gallery for art. And this includes my stuff too. Just because I draw a bunch of pin-ups, doesn't mean it should be replacements for actual page updates.


About the Shadowgirls forum

Most Users Ever Online:

20


Currently Online:

6 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 8

Topics: 117

Posts: 3207

Membership:

There are 200 Members

There has been 1 Guest

There are 3 Admins

There are 3 Moderators

Top Posters:

adamas – 345

Jacobus – 303

Forsythe – 271

SporkBot – 267

Bounty – 244

Tain – 208

Administrators: Dave Reynolds (310 Posts), D-Rod (58 Posts), Frumph (2 Posts)

Moderators: Dave Reynolds (310 Posts), D-Rod (58 Posts), Tink (281 Posts)